Court Submissions

Example Structure

Here’s an in-depth breakdown of the structure of a court submission in Hong Kong:

1. Court Heading

   • Court Name: The name of the court where the submission is filed (e.g., High Court of Hong Kong).

   • Case Number: The unique number assigned to the case by the court.

   • Title of Proceedings: The names of the parties involved.

   Example:

   High Court of Hong Kong Case No. HCA1234/2023 Between: Plaintiff: John Doe and Defendant: XYZ Corporation

2. Title of the Submission

   • Title: Clearly specify the purpose of the submission (e.g., "Plaintiff’s Submission on Legal Arguments").

   Example:

   PLAINTIFF’S SUBMISSION ON LEGAL ARGUMENTS

3. Introduction

   • Purpose of Submission: Briefly state the purpose of the submission and provide a summary of the issues at hand.

   Example:

   This submission outlines the legal arguments supporting the Plaintiff's claim against the Defendant for breach of contract.

4. Background

   • Factual Background: Provide a summary of the relevant facts and procedural history that led to the submission. This section should briefly describe the context of the case.

   Example:

   On January 1, 2023, the Plaintiff and Defendant entered into a contract for the sale of goods. The Defendant failed to deliver the goods by the agreed date, resulting in financial losses for the Plaintiff.

5. Legal Issues

   • Identification of Issues: Clearly identify the legal issues that the submission addresses. This section should outline the specific questions the court needs to resolve.

   Example:

   The primary legal issues are: 1. Whether the Defendant breached the contract by failing to deliver the goods on time. 2. The amount of damages the Plaintiff is entitled to as a result of this breach.

6. Legal Arguments

   • Detailed Analysis: Present the legal arguments in a clear and structured manner. Use headings and subheadings to organize different points. Support arguments with relevant statutes, case law, and legal precedents.

   Example:

   A. Breach of Contract Under the Contract Ordinance (Cap. 26), a party breaches a contract when they fail to perform their obligations under the agreement. In *Smith v. Jones* [2020] HKCA 123, the court held that timely delivery is an essential term of a sales contract. B. Damages The Plaintiff claims damages amounting to HKD 100,000, which is the loss incurred due to the Defendant's failure to deliver the goods. Under the principle established in *Hadley v. Baxendale* [1854] 9 Exch 341, the Plaintiff is entitled to recover losses that were reasonably foreseeable at the time of contracting.

7. Conclusion

   • Summary of Requests: Summarize the key arguments and explicitly state the relief sought from the court.

   Example:

   In conclusion, the Plaintiff respectfully requests that the court find in favor of the Plaintiff, declare that the Defendant breached the contract, and award damages in the amount of HKD 100,000.

8. Signature Block

   • Signatures: Include spaces for the signatures of the parties or their legal representatives.

   Example:

   Dated this [Date] day of [Month], [Year]. [Signature] [Name] [Law Firm Name, if applicable]

​

Dos and Don’ts

• Do: Use clear and concise language; ensure all arguments are logically structured.

• Don’t: Include irrelevant information or make unsubstantiated claims.

​

Tips

• Use bullet points or numbered lists to enhance readability.

• Cite sources accurately to strengthen legal arguments.

​

Common Errors

• Lack of Clarity: Ambiguous statements or poorly structured arguments can undermine the submission.

• Non-Compliance with Court Rules: Failing to adhere to the required format or procedural rules can lead to rejection.

​

Solutions

• Review the submission for clarity and logical flow before filing.

• Ensure compliance with the Rules of the High Court and any specific court directions regarding submissions.