Ethical Decision Making

Why Ethical Decision Making Matters

​

What is Ethical Decision Making?

At its core, ethical decision-making is about figuring out the right course of action when faced with dilemmas in legal practice. It requires you to balance your duties to clients, the court, and society, all while holding fast to the ethical standards that define our profession. This isn’t just a theoretical exercise; it’s a vital skill that will shape your career and the trust the public places in lawyers.

​

Why Should You Care?

1. Building Public Trust: The legal profession thrives on public confidence. When you act ethically, you contribute to a positive perception of lawyers and the justice system.

   • Example: Imagine a lawyer who consistently treats clients fairly and honestly. Such behavior not only earns respect but also leads to referrals and a solid reputation in the community.

2. Upholding Professional Standards: Adhering to ethical guidelines ensures that you maintain the integrity of your profession.

   • Example: A lawyer who stands firm against unethical practices, even when faced with pressure, demonstrates a commitment to the highest standards of professional conduct.

3. Avoiding Misconduct: Making ethical decisions helps you steer clear of actions that could result in disciplinary measures or legal consequences.

   • Example: By recognizing the potential issues with accepting gifts from clients, you can avoid conflicts of interest and maintain your professional integrity.

​

Ethical Frameworks in Hong Kong

​

1. The Solicitors Ordinance and the Law Society of Hong Kong

The Solicitors Ordinance lays down the conduct expected of solicitors in Hong Kong, outlining the standards that govern professional behavior.

• Example: The Law Society’s Code of Practice mandates that solicitors act with integrity, respect client confidentiality, and avoid conflicts of interest. Understanding these rules is crucial as you prepare for practice.

​

2. The Hong Kong Bar Association

For barristers, the Hong Kong Bar Association provides a comprehensive set of guidelines that govern professional conduct.

• Example: Barristers must maintain independence and impartiality in their advocacy, ensuring their ethical obligations to the court are never compromised.

​

3. The Basic Law and International Treaties

Hong Kong's legal framework is influenced by the Basic Law and various international treaties that emphasize human rights and justice.

• Example: When representing clients, lawyers must consider international human rights conventions, especially in cases involving free speech or due process, ensuring they uphold both local and global standards.

​

Your Guide to Ethical Decision Making

​

Step-by-Step Process

​

1. Identify the Ethical Dilemma

Start by clearly defining the issue at hand. This means understanding the situation fully and recognizing where your obligations might conflict.

• Example 1: You find out your client intends to commit perjury. Do you continue representing them or take action to prevent it?

• Example 2: A colleague is mishandling client funds. You need to figure out whether to confront them directly or report the misconduct.

​

2. Gather Relevant Information

Collect all pertinent facts, legal principles, and ethical guidelines that may inform your decision.

• Example 1: Review the Law Society’s Code of Practice regarding client obligations and your duty to the court.

• Example 2: Consult past cases that address similar ethical dilemmas to understand how they were resolved.

​

3. Consider the Impact

Think through the potential consequences of your actions on your client, the court, and society at large. This is where you weigh the long-term implications of your choices.

• Example 1: If you choose to represent a client intending to commit perjury, you risk your reputation and could face disciplinary action.

• Example 2: Reporting your colleague’s misconduct might strain your working relationships, but it’s essential for protecting the integrity of the practice.

​

4. Evaluate Options

Identify and assess the various courses of action. Consider the legal and ethical implications of each.

• Example 1: You might:

  • Continue representation while advising against perjury.

  • Withdraw from representation and inform the court.

  • Report the client’s intentions to the appropriate authorities.

• Example 2: For the legal assistant, possible actions could include:

  • Directly discussing the issue with the colleague.

  • Reporting the misconduct to a supervisor.

  • Seeking guidance from a mentor or the Law Society.

​

5. Make a Decision

Choose the action that best aligns with your ethical obligations and professional responsibilities.

• Example 1: A lawyer decides to withdraw from representation, documenting the reasons for this choice to protect themselves in the future.

• Example 2: The legal assistant opts to report the misconduct to ensure accountability and uphold ethical standards.

​

6. Document the Decision-Making Process

Keep detailed records of how you arrived at your decision, including the information considered and the rationale behind your chosen course of action.

• Example 1: Documenting discussions with clients about their intentions can serve as a protective measure in case disputes arise later.

• Example 2: The legal assistant should record observations, steps taken to address the misconduct, and any communications with supervisors.

​

Real-World Scenarios in Hong Kong

​

Scenario 1: Conflict of Interest

A lawyer is approached by two parties in a dispute. Representing both could create a conflict of interest.

• Decision Making: Assess your obligations to each client and determine whether to represent one party or both. It’s essential to disclose the potential conflict to both clients and obtain informed consent if you choose to proceed.

​

Scenario 2: Confidentiality Breach

A lawyer inadvertently receives sensitive information from an opposing party.

• Decision Making: Evaluate your duty to maintain client confidentiality while considering whether to inform your client about the information received. Determine the best course of action to avoid breaching ethical obligations.

​

Scenario 3: Misleading the Court

A lawyer realizes that evidence submitted in court was misleading.

• Decision Making: You have a duty to rectify the situation. Decide whether to inform the court about the misleading evidence, which may involve withdrawing from the case if the client refuses to correct the record.

​

Scenario 4: Handling Client Funds

A lawyer discovers discrepancies in their handling of client funds during a routine audit.

• Decision Making: You must investigate further, report the issue to the Law Society, and take corrective action to ensure compliance with ethical standards and protect client interests.

​

Conclusion

Ethical decision-making is not just an academic concept; it’s a vital skill for navigating the complexities of legal practice in Hong Kong. By understanding the ethical frameworks that govern your conduct and applying a structured approach to resolving dilemmas, you can face challenging situations with integrity and professionalism. Upholding ethical standards protects your clients, enhances the credibility of the legal profession, and contributes to the overall integrity of the justice system. As you embark on your legal career, remember that fostering a culture of ethical awareness and decision-making is essential—not just for you, but for the future of the legal profession as a whole.